← All candidatesEngine Activity
Emma Navarro vs Karolina Muchova
Emma Navarro to win · Moneyline
Decision
- Outcome
- Pass
- Main reason
- Evidence grade below the lockable set (and 1 more)
- Decided
- 2026-09-04 07:39:37 UTC
- Policy
- v1.1
Gates that did not pass
- UncertaintyEvidence grade below the lockable setFailed
- Adversarial reviewAdversarial review found a blocking objectionFailed
Full gate trace (9 gates)
- Event integrityReal, identified, pre-match fixture inside the lock windowPassed
- EvidenceMaterial claims supported by enough distinct sourcesPassed
- PriceRecorded price clears the minimum qualifying oddsPassed
- Price sourcePrice attributable to an identified source (global reference only)Passed
- FreshnessPrice, evidence and personnel information within the age limitsPassed
- UncertaintyEvidence grade below the lockable setFailed
- Adversarial reviewAdversarial review found a blocking objectionFailed
- DuplicationNo existing position on this eventPassed
- PresentationPresentation compliantPassed
Why it entered research
Deterministic screening facts recorded when the scan admitted this selection. No model was involved at this step.
- Price above the de-vigged fair price
- Enough operators for a market reference
- Price inside the freshness limit
- Screened
- 2026-09-04 07:07:01 UTC
- Market
- Moneyline
- Best verified price
- 4.670
- Market reference
- 4.200 · 11 operators
- Minimum Qualifying Odds
- 4.57 · edge 5.78%
Research
US Open 2026: Emma Navarro vs Karolina Muchova Matchup Analysis
Evaluation of the US Open 2026 third-round matchup between Emma Navarro and Karolina Muchova scheduled for September 4, 2026, highlighting a significant market pricing discrepancy alongside critical execution risks.
Primary case
- Emma Navarro (seeded 26th) is scheduled to face Karolina Muchova (seeded 7th) in the third round of the US Open on September 4, 2026 (CL-81f43296-5f1, CL-64d6ae8f-8ed, CL-0b3a637e-1e4, CL-814cefeb-228).
- Both players are also listed among notable participants for the Wuhan Open event (CL-11876264-7cb).
Market context
- The best global decimal price available is 4.670 offered by BetOnlineAG in the US region, which exceeds the acceptable price threshold of 4.57.
- The market reference price is 4.200, determined by the median of 11 operators, with a de-vigged fair decimal price of 4.415 based on a fair probability of 22.65 percent and an overround of 5.11 percent.
- There is a high dispersion of 11.19 percent across the 11 tracked operators, and there is insufficient historical data with only one price sample observed at 4.420.
What the price requires
- The price requires that the best global price of 4.670 at BetOnlineAG is actionable and executable with meaningful liquidity, despite the best_executable field being null.
- It assumes the de-vigged fair price of 4.415 accurately captures the true match odds despite the high 11.19 percent price dispersion across operators.
Major uncertainty
There is no verified executable market price available (best_executable is null), creating critical execution risk and suggesting that the 4.670 price from BetOnlineAG may be an unexecutable outlier.
Material findings and their support
- Line-up · material · for the caseEmma Navarro is scheduled to face Karolina Muchova in the third round (Round of 32) of the US Open on September 4, 2026.Supported
- Statistic · for the caseKarolina Muchova is seeded 7th and Emma Navarro is seeded 26th at the tournament.Supported
- Other · material · for the caseEmma Navarro faces Karolina Muchova in the third round of the US Open Women's Singles 2026.Supported
- Other · material · for the caseKarolina Muchova, seeded 7th, faces Emma Navarro, seeded 26th, in the US Open third round on September 4, 2026.Supported
- Other · material · for the caseKarolina Muchova and Emma Navarro were listed among notable participants for the Wuhan Open event.Supported
Adversarial review
The strongest case against the candidate, as recorded before the decision.
There is no verified executable market price available (best_executable is null), making locking a position indefensible due to critical execution risk.
Blocking questions
- Why is best_executable null, and can an executable quote be confirmed at or above the 4.57 threshold before locking?
- What account limits and liquidity exist at BetOnlineAG to execute at 4.670?
- What accounts for the high 11.19% price dispersion among the 11 operators?
Why the market may simply be right
- The market median reference price of 4.200 properly reflects the baseline probability given Muchova's #7 seed advantage over Navarro's #26 seed, implying that 4.670 may be an unexecutable outlier.